For James “Jim” D. Penny J.D. ’83 and his late wife, Pamela “Pam” Jordan Penny ’77, HON J.D. ’16, giving back to William & Mary was never about simply making a donation. It’s been about investing in people, strengthening institutions and ensuring future generations have opportunities to learn, lead and serve.

In recognition of that enduring commitment, William & Mary has selected the Pennys as recipients of this year’s Prentis Award. Presented annually, the award recognizes exemplary civic service to the university and the broader community. Jim will receive the award during a private event on Nov. 30.

“Jim and Pam’s impact can be felt across all walks of William & Mary’s campus,” said President Katherine A. Rowe. “I’ve witnessed firsthand their dedication to our community over the years – Pam, through her work with the Society of 1918, Mason School of Business, and the W&M Foundation, and Jim, through his leadership at the Law School, Tribe Athletics, and the Muscarelle Museum. I cherish their friendship, and it is a privilege to honor them both with the Prentis Award.”

The honor celebrates a partnership that spanned more than four decades, encompassing leadership, philanthropy and a deep commitment to the institutions and causes that mattered most to the couple.

The Pennys’ connection to William & Mary was built through decades of engagement — as alumni, volunteers, leaders and benefactors. But perhaps their most enduring contribution is the example they set: that a meaningful relationship with a university does not end at graduation, and that giving back can take many forms — time, expertise, leadership, financial support and a willingness to answer the call when needed.

A partnership rooted at William & Mary

The Pennys’ story began in Norfolk, where both were working in public accounting. They met at a new employee reception hosted by their firm. They married in 1983.

Both would go on to build distinguished careers. Jim left accounting for William & Mary Law School, fulfilling a longstanding ambition to become a lawyer. After six years in Norfolk, Pam’s career took her to Houston, where she ultimately became an audit partner at KPMG.
She later moved into corporate finance, serving as senior vice president and controller of American General Corporation before becoming executive vice president and chief accounting officer of HCC Insurance Holdings, Inc., a New York Stock Exchange-listed company.

Jim spent more than 30 years practicing tax law at Vinson & Elkins LLP in Houston, retiring in 2015. Pam retired in 2016.

After 33 years in Houston, the couple returned to Williamsburg, a place they had long envisioned as home. They purchased Bel-Mede, an 18th-century house in a neighborhood near campus, in 2008 and spent years restoring and expanding the property before moving to Williamsburg permanently in 2016.

Their return marked a new chapter in an already substantial record of service.

Serve and return

Jim’s involvement with William & Mary grew from an early effort to reconnect with classmates. As he approached a reunion, a fellow alumnus encouraged him to help organize the event.
That involvement soon expanded. He became active with W&M Law School, serving as co-chair of several reunions and helping establish and deliver on ambitious fundraising goals.
He went on to serve as president and trustee of the William & Mary Law School Foundation, of which he is now an emeritus member of the board, and has held leadership roles in the university’s fundraising efforts, including chairing the law school’s For the Bold Campaign Steering Committee.

Pam’s engagement was equally consequential, though it developed along a different path. Having worked at Swem Library as a student, she became increasingly involved in supporting the libraries. Later, she served on the Accounting Programs Board at the Raymond A. Mason School of Business and became a trustee of the William & Mary Foundation, where she chaired the Academic Initiatives Subcommittee and the Audit Committee, and served on the Trusteeship Committee and the Executive Committee.

She also helped establish the Society of 1918, dedicated to growing the engagement, leadership and philanthropy of William & Mary women. As a charter member, Pam drafted the organization’s bylaws and served in several leadership capacities, including five years as chair of its Membership Committee. During that period, membership grew to more than 700.

“Pam was on the initial steering committee, but she was more than just a member,” said Cindy Jarboe ’77, another Society of 1918 founder. “She realized right away how big an impact the society could have on engagement, so she wanted to be sure we had the right structure. The bylaws she drafted have stood the test of time. Without Pam’s efforts, the society would not have the impact it has had.”

An all-campus approach

Together, the Pennys made significant investments across campus. Their $1 million commitment helped create Penny Commons, a modern atrium and gathering space in the law school’s Hixon Center for Experiential Learning and Leadership. Dedicated in 2016, the space provides a meeting place for students working in clinical areas as well as a venue for university events and receptions.

They also established the Penny Professorship of Law, the Penny Professorship of Accounting, the Penny Accounting Scholarship and the Penny Business Analytics Scholarship at the business school, while supporting numerous building campaigns and other university priorities.
For the Pennys, these investments in facilities and academic programs reflected a belief that philanthropy should have a lasting impact.

As Pam once explained, giving back helps encourage future generations of William & Mary graduates to support the university.

Pam was named an honorary alumna of William & Mary Law School in 2016 and received the university’s Alumni Medallion in 2024, recognizing her professional accomplishments, service and extraordinary dedication to her alma mater.

“Jim and Pam have long embodied what it means to be servant leaders and William & Mary has greatly benefited from their dedication,” said Matthew T. Lambert ’99, senior vice president for university advancement. “Their devotion to alma mater and selfless service to the entire community have bolstered the university in myriad areas, and we are deeply grateful. We know that Jim will continue to carry that legacy forward with Pam’s encouragement, at William & Mary and throughout our community.”

A commitment extending beyond campus

The Pennys’ interests extended beyond William & Mary.

One organization particularly close to Pam’s heart was Child Development Resources, a Williamsburg-area nonprofit providing services to young children and their families, along with training and technical assistance for professionals who work with them.

The couple’s community service also included the Jamestown Rediscovery Foundation, where she served on the Board of Trustees and as treasurer, as well as support for The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, the Jamestown-Yorktown Foundation and George Washington’s Mount Vernon. They recently helped organize and raise funding for an award-winning exhibition of rare ancient Chinese porcelain found at Historic Jamestown.

Jim has continued that shared commitment to history and preservation. He chairs the board of the Art Museums of Colonial Williamsburg and serves as vice chair of the Muscarelle Museum of Art at William & Mary.

In Pam’s memory, he recently donated artwork by celebrated ceramicist Michelle Erickson ’82.
“Jim’s deep engagement at the Muscarelle Museum of Art highlights his care for the well-being of both the university and the greater community,” said David Brashear HON ’07, the museum’s director. “His commitment to ensuring that all are welcome at the Muscarelle has helped us become a more important part of the Williamsburg experience.”

Carrying the legacy forward

The significance of the Prentis Award was especially evident during a recent visit to campus, when Jim attended a William & Mary Foundation Board gathering. The program began with a celebration of Pam’s life and contributions. He also visited the plaque in Pam’s memory in Gates Hall.

For Jim, these reminders of Pam’s influence are more than memorials. They represent the results of a lifetime spent building relationships and supporting institutions that make a difference.

, Communications Specialist